Skip to content
Advertisement · Sponsored by CHIPEC CONSEIL SAS A private information site, not a government service · Legal notice
Newsletter
Everyday money · Question

TFSA or RRSP: which should you use first?

Answered by the UV Bench desk ·
Short answer

It depends on your income now versus in retirement. A TFSA suits lower or uncertain income and gives tax-free withdrawals; an RRSP suits higher earners who expect a lower tax rate later.

A person at a kitchen table with a laptop and a notebook, working out a budget, daylight.

It is the question almost every Canadian saver hits sooner or later: money is going aside, but into which account? The Tax-Free Savings Account and the Registered Retirement Savings Plan both shelter your money from tax — but they do it in opposite directions, and the better choice depends on your own income now versus later.

Here is how to tell them apart, and how to decide which one to fill first.

The one-line difference

An RRSP gives you a tax deduction now and is taxed when you take it out. A TFSA gives no deduction now, but everything comes out tax-free — growth included. One defers tax; the other removes it on the way out.

How each one works

With an RRSP, a contribution reduces your taxable income for the year, so you pay less tax now (or get a refund). The money grows sheltered, and you pay tax when you withdraw it — usually in retirement, when many people are in a lower bracket. Your RRSP must be converted to a RRIF (or annuity) by the end of the year you turn 71.

With a TFSA, you contribute money you've already paid tax on, so there's no deduction. In return, nothing inside is ever taxed again, and withdrawals don't count as income. A useful quirk: when you take money out of a TFSA, that contribution room comes back the following calendar year.

When the TFSA usually wins

  • Your income is lower now than it's likely to be later, so a deduction today is worth less than tax-free income tomorrow.
  • You might need the money before retirement — TFSA withdrawals are tax-free and flexible.
  • You're worried about income-tested benefits in retirement: TFSA withdrawals don't count as income, so they don't claw back things like the GST/HST credit or Old Age Security the way RRSP/RRIF income can.

When the RRSP usually wins

  • You're a higher earner now and expect a lower tax rate in retirement — the deduction is worth more today than the tax you'll pay later.
  • You want the discipline of money that's harder to dip into.
  • Your employer matches RRSP contributions — that match is effectively free money and usually comes first, whatever else you do.
TFSA vs RRSP, side by side (illustrative)
TFSARRSP
Deduction now?NoYes
Taxed on withdrawal?NoYes
Withdrawal counts as income?NoYes
Best when your rate is…lower now / uncertainhigher now, lower later

A simplified comparison. Contribution room, the exact limits and special rules change year to year — check your own room in CRA My Account.

A simple way to decide

A rough rule many people use: if you're in a lower tax bracket now, lean TFSA; if you're in a higher bracket now and expect to drop in retirement, lean RRSP. Take any employer RRSP match first. And it isn't either/or — plenty of people use both, often RRSP for the deduction and TFSA for flexibility.

Watch your contribution room. Over-contributing to either account triggers a CRA penalty of 1% a month on the excess. Your exact room is shown in CRA My Account — don't rely on memory or a rule of thumb.

What about the FHSA?

If you're saving for a first home, there's a third option that can beat both for that goal: the First Home Savings Account gives an RRSP-style deduction and a tax-free withdrawal for a qualifying home. We cover it in how the First Home Savings Account works. And wherever your savings sit, it's worth knowing they're protected if a bank fails — see is your money safe if a bank fails.

Common questions

Can I have both a TFSA and an RRSP?

Yes. They have separate contribution limits and many people use both — the RRSP for the deduction, the TFSA for flexible, tax-free savings.

If I take money out of my TFSA, is it gone for good?

No. The amount you withdraw is added back to your contribution room, but only in the next calendar year. Re-contributing in the same year can cause an over-contribution.

Is the RRSP refund "free money"?

It's your own deferred tax. You'll pay tax when you withdraw, so the benefit depends on your tax rate being lower then than now.

In short

Neither account is better in the abstract. The TFSA removes tax on the way out and suits lower or uncertain incomes and anyone wanting flexibility; the RRSP defers tax and suits higher earners expecting a lower rate later. Grab any employer match first, check your real contribution room in CRA My Account, and remember you can use both.

Sources

  1. Canada.ca · Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) — how the TFSA works, limits and withdrawals
  2. Canada.ca · RRSPs and related plans — deductions, withdrawals and converting to a RRIF
  3. Canada.ca · Savings and pension plans — overview of registered accounts

This is general information and sponsored content from CHIPEC CONSEIL SAS. It is not financial, tax or legal advice, and not a recommendation to buy any product. Figures are rounded examples or current limits, correct as at the date shown, and your situation may differ. UV Bench is not the CRA, Service Canada, CDIC, the CRTC or any government body, and does not process any application. For your own situation, use the official sources cited above, such as canada.ca.

Three questions a week, clearly answered.